First released: October 2012
About
Disc 1
- 1.Welcome0:29
- 2.Weep Jeremiah (parody of Sweet Child O' Mine by Guns 'N' Roses)5:25
- 3.Circus Performers1:06
- 4.Huge Slumber Party (parody of Use Somebody by Kings of Leon)3:40
- 5.Samuel Gets Selective1:31
- 6.Jesse's Boy (parody of Jesse's Girl by Rick Springfield)3:06
- 7.Stop Caring1:08
- 8.Dancing with the Ark3:40
- 9.Kazoo Kommentary2:35
- 10.Tenacious Todd's Tale7:36
- 11.Judge (parody of Jump by Van Halen)4:24
- 12.Nothing to Sneeze At4:48
- 13.Baa! We're Lambs (parody of Barbara Ann by The Beach Boys)2:18
- 14.Search and You'll Get Saved (parody of Surfin' USA by The Beach Boys)2:35
- 15.Stand-Up Guy0:58
- 16.Found God (parody of Hound Dog by Elvis Presley)2:30
- 17.Hit a Low C0:23
- 18.For Just You (parody of Forget You by Cee Lo Green)3:45
- 19.Equal Time for Esau0:32
- 20.Sweet Oholibamah (parody of Sweet Alabama by Lynyrd Skynyrd)4:38
- 21.Marco Polo4:39
- 22.Ain't That a Miracle (parody of Pink Houses by John Cougar Mellencamp)4:39
- 23.Need-to-Know Bassist3:12
- 24.Lived the Day You Died (parody of Love the Way You Lie by Eminem featuring Rihanna)4:45
Disc 2
- 1.Thrilling Announcement2:23
- 2.Keep Your Ham to Yourself (parody of Keep Your Hands to Yourself by Georgia Satellites)4:22
- 3.Pilate Episode0:27
- 4.Too Much Grime on My Hands (parody of Too Much Time on My Hands by Styx)4:21
- 5.You Could Be Famous0:20
- 6.Monkeys for Uncles (parody of Money for Nothing by Dire Straits)6:09
- 7.All in the Family1:52
- 8.Meshach (parody of Love Shack by B-52s)4:26
- 9.Trials & Trios1:44
- 10.Anniversary Medley6:29
- 11.Good News/Bad News13:06
- 12.Want It Dead or Alive (parody of Wanted Dead or Alive by Bon Jovi)4:51
- 13.Paul's Lady Friend1:15
- 14.Aquila (parody of Aqualung by Jethro Tull)5:09
- 15.Catch That Fever! (parody of Cat Scratch Fever by Ted Nugent)7:01